Our agency’s workflow used to look like this, and while it went well most of the time… it also led to heartache, never-ending projects, and early-onset baldness due to pulling all of our hair out:
- Conduct all research
- Create copy & design, obsess over it, make it perfect
- Show client & hope for the best
Why was this a disaster?
In all honesty, projects went well most of the time. And maybe you’ve experienced the same.
Clients come to us because they trust us and love our aesthetic, so they typically love what we create.
💔 Falling out of love with your clients? Trade some of your worst clients for the best companies in the world with SolidGigs, our premium weekly freelance job list & course library. Love your business again. Learn more »
But there’s a big risk in doing things this way: We put a lot of our eggs in one basket for step #2. But what if the client hated it? What if the direction was all wrong? What if they wanted / expected something completely different?
We’d have to go back to square one after putting in the sweat, blood, and hours that go into a final proof. Or, we’d have to spend hours in back-and-forth justifying our decisions to the client and ultimately getting them to sign off on something they just didn’t like.
(And not every client is sophisticated or impartial enough to set their own preferences aside in the name of giving the market what it wants.)
But in my experience, a lot of freelancers and agencies follow a similar workflow, and face similar disasters. I think this is why:
Enter your email. Grow your business.
Submit your email below and join 45,000+ creatives who get our most helpful content via email every week. 100% free. Unsubscribe anytime. Privacy protected.
The fear of too many cooks in the kitchen.
We’ve all had experiences where the client weighed in on every stage of a project, and that, in short, was a nightmare.
It gave us no space to stretch out and let our creativity expand and flow.
We hated feeling micromanaged.
We dreaded feedback.
So after living through that, my conclusion, and maybe yours too, was to limit feedback as much as possible. Heck – why not make feedback just at the very end… and nowhere in between?
But there were times where this went wrong… horribly wrong.
And those times hurt. Bad. Because we put days, weeks, into a proof that got rejected faster than [insert pop culture dating reference here… because I am totally up to date on that stuff].
The worst part is after you show a concept that a client hates, you’re then sort of stuck being micromanaged. Because what else is there to do from that point on than to just keep showing them concept after concept until you finally strike gold and they say yes?
These experiences killed my morale, made me want to quit altogether at times, and sucked up time I could have used on other projects, growth, and my personal life.
Impossible to scale.
This workflow presents another issue as well: It makes it extremely hard to scale your business.
When client approval is a crapshoot, where it’s either a “hell yes!” or a “hell no, start over” – and you can never predict when it’ll happen – you can only grow so much.
Your growth depends on your time. And if you don’t know when all of your time will be taken up for months on end with never-ending projects that never get approved…
It’s really hard to grow.
Introducing: the “3 bears” middle ground.
Involve the client too much, and sure, you won’t risk spending tons of time on a “wrong” direction – but you do face the soul-crushing reality of being micromanaged.
Involve the client too little – and you face the other picture painted above.
So what’s the alternative? Like Goldilocks and her 3 bowls of stolen porridge, you have to involve the client “just right.”
To do that, we tested & refined this workflow. So far, it’s worked wonders:
- Conduct all research
- Outline a creative brief including overall design / copy direction and get the client to sign off on it
- Get copy approved
- Create a rough concept based on the approved direction that includes some of the copy laid out, and get it signed off on
- Go to town. Put your heart & soul into creating a finished product knowing your client is happy with the direction (and you have email proof confirming it).
- Share with the client and make small revisions as necessary
- Voila! Project complete
We bypass micromanagement, endless revisions, and flat out “no”s by getting the client to sign off on things. Twice.
We keep them “out of the kitchen” when we’re doing the cooking, but basically appear every now and then to give them a taste and ask if it needs some salt.
Because when you think about it, there are two places where projects go wrong:
- The client just hates the overall direction / angle you took
- The client likes the direction, but just isn’t crazy about how you executed it
#1 is solved by creating a brief. #2 is solved by showing an initial concept.
It sounds simple, and I wonder how we didn’t think of it sooner, but it’s worked like magic for us since we started implementing it.
An important question: “How much time do I put into this initial concept though?”
Think of it like this: If you’re designing a website, maybe put a good bit of effort into creating the “above the fold” section of the home page. Or if you’re too hesitant to do even that, maybe compile a “mood board” of samples that you feel capture what you’re going for and pass that along.
A mood board is a great tool that can eliminate the need to create a concept if the examples are striking enough and telling enough of what you plan to do.
But ultimately, a concept is still safer because you never know what the client “saw” in your examples. They may have walked away from the mood board with a completely different idea.
(Sometimes we’ve done both mood boards and concepts when we sensed confusion from the client – that’s a great fail-safe I think.)
Simple? Yes. Effective? Very.
With that said, I know we have room to grow even more. Do you have any great workflow tips for approval you can share?
I’d love to hear about them. Leave me a comment and let’s discuss.
Keep the conversation going...
Over 5,000 of us are having daily conversations over in our free Facebook group and we'd love to see you there. Join us!